Overview
PEACE PIE is the Patented Ice Cream Sandwich with a Layer of Pie Filling! Each of our 30+ flavors have a layer of our signature house-made toppings. From our original classic Pecan Pie to our best seller Salted Caramel Brownie, there is something for everyone. Have the ultimate Ice Cream Sandwich experience at our shop located in historic downtown St. Augustine. Indoor/Outdoor Seating, Open 7 days a week. Catering & Vending services are available. Delivery and pickup options available online.
The Peace Pie Story is rooted in the true spirit of the American dream. Six years ago, founder and creator Jerry Klause, made an ice cream Pecan Pie Lasagna for family and friends to enjoy. He realized immediately that he had stumbled across a delicious creation that was sure to be loved by the masses. Peace Pies makes the ultimate artisan ice cream sandwich - with a layer of pie filling. Using specialty premium house-made ice cream along with home-made pie fillings, brownies and caramel. Peace Pies takes an artistic approach to ice cream.
Cuisines
- Ice Cream
Amenities
- Family-Friendly
- Group-Friendly
- Outdoor Seating
- Pet-Friendly
Reviews
Trip Advisor Reviews
Related Content

Shake Night
Friday night is Shake Night with 8 specialty flavors featured each week!
Summer Fresh 6 Pack
Enjoy one of each flavor Peace Pie: -Key Lime -Strawberry Shortcake -Chocolate Mint -Coconut Cream -The Elvis -Triple Vanilla (Price…
Chocolate Lover’s 6 pack
Enjoy one of each flavor Peace Pie: -Triple Chocolate Brownie -Cookie Dough -Candy Bar -The Elvis -Molten Chocolate -Salted Caramel…

Flagler Student Discount
Flagler college students show your student I.D. for $1 off your Peace Pie.

Shake Night
Friday night is Shake Night with 8 specialty flavors featured each week!
Summer Fresh 6 Pack
Enjoy one of each flavor Peace Pie: -Key Lime -Strawberry Shortcake -Chocolate Mint -Coconut Cream -The Elvis -Triple Vanilla (Price…
Chocolate Lover’s 6 pack
Enjoy one of each flavor Peace Pie: -Triple Chocolate Brownie -Cookie Dough -Candy Bar -The Elvis -Molten Chocolate -Salted Caramel…

Unique Dining Experiences
The culinary scene in St. Augustine is as storied as its history.

Flagler Student Discount
Flagler college students show your student I.D. for $1 off your Peace Pie.

Bulk Orders/Special Events
We offer discounted prices for weddings and special events! Build your own bulk with as many flavors as you like…