The 10 Top Fine Dining Spots in St. Augustine
Whether you’re celebrating a milestone or simply treating yourself, discover culinary favorites in the fine-dining world of St. Augustine.
St. Augustine is home to a lush and growing culinary scene that brings new cuisines to the tables of locals and visitors alike. From Peruvian cuisine at Llama Restaurant to Japanese tastes at Lotus Noodle Bar to fine French food at La Nouvelle and so much more, you’ll be able to treat yourself to a huge selection of international cuisines right here in St. Augustine.
Ponte Vedra Beach & St. Augustine Beach
Lotus Noodle Bar
56 Grove Ave.
St. Augustine, FL
Lotus Noodle’s Reservation
Lotus Noodle Bar serves an original fusion of Japanese and French flavors that is, simply put, refined, devine and delicious. Named on the restaurant recommendations list for Florida by the Michelin Guide in 2026, Lotus Noodle Bar cemented its place not only as a true fine-dining experience but also as a respected culinary establishment.
Inside their open-concept dining space, you’ll be greeted with warm hues and wood accents that let the menu do all the talking. Choose from their entrees of unique ramen dishes made creatively with braised brisket, truffle, bacon, lobster and crab. Kick off your meal with a shareable like their Japanese Tartare or their Not So Traditional Caviar Service made with Japanese ikura.
For a unique fine-dining experience, reserve a spot at their evening events with the chef. During these events, you’ll have the opportunity to meet with Lotus Noodle Bar’s chef, learn more about the cuisine and experience culinary craftsmanship through curated bites.
Llama Restaurant
415 Anastasia Blvd.
St. Augustine, FL
Llama Restaurant’s Reservations
For a Peruvian fine-dining experience, head to Llama Restaurant. Due to the modest space, you’ll need to reserve a table ahead of time, but the intimate setting helps you feel like part of the family with the staff’s welcoming attitudes and the menu’s familial recipes. And don’t be fooled: each plate is packed full of flavor and culture thanks to Head Chef Marcel.
The professionally trained chef took inspiration from his heritage, dishes from his culture and a few pages out of his mother’s recipe book to create the menu, highlighting Peruvian cuisine with his own personal creative twists. And, after just five years, the restaurant earned national acclaim when it earned a spot on OpenTable’s Top 100 Restaurants in the Nation for 2023.
This highly regarded restaurant is a delicious choice for treating yourself and is perfect for culinary explorers looking to try unique plates that they cannot taste anywhere else.
Asado Life
173 Shipyard Way
St. Augustine, FL
Asado Life’s Reservations
Another Michelin-recommended restaurant, Asado Life, brings fine dining to the waterside with its Shipyard Marina location in St. Augustine. At Asado Life, everything — from the chorizo links to the bread dough — is made from scratch, which gives their team of professionally trained chefs the opportunity to put their St. Augustine twist into every bite.
One of the unique experiences from Asado Life is their barbecue and smoked offerings that are slow-cooked before guests’ very eyes. This not only adds to the flavors but also enriches the air with the mouthwatering scents of fish, ribs and steak.
Their larger menu also gives you the chance to pick from an appetizer list that is just as tasty as their entrees and a means to turn dinner into an event with their Chef’s Table option. This puts your course lineup in the hands of the chefs to curate an appetizer, dinner and dessert of their own choosing.
Ruth’s Chris Steak House
814 A1A N., Ste. 103
Ponte Vedra Beach, FL
Ruth’s Chris Steak House’s Reservations
If you’re looking for a dining option with a traditional American menu, Ruth’s Chris Steak House’s location in Ponte Vedra Beach offers a menu featuring classic barbecue, steak and seafood dishes to be enjoyed in their sophisticated dining space.
Their steak variety and trained chefs give you the chance to have a steak to your liking made with local beef and fresh ingredients. It all starts with you choosing your cut, from a center-cut filet to ribeye to New York strip to tomahawk and more.
Though their menu keeps these staples, Ruth’s Chris’ chefs also create seasonal bites to complement the produce in season. If you’re not sure where to start with their detailed offerings, opt for one of the Chef Picks!
Historic Downtown
Collage
60 Hypolita St.
St. Augustine, FL
Collage’s Reservations
In the Old City district, inside the warm and intimate dining space of the Spanish-style building on Hypolita St., you’ll find a delectable collage of international cuisines and a melting pot of cultures. Creating a hub for global tastes is a point of pride for Collage, which hangs its motto, “artful global dining,” above its door.
Their professional chefs craft seasonal and international meals that highlight a myriad of cuisines that take guests on a culinary journey around the world, all from their location in St. Augustine. Grab a seat at one of their white-tableclothed tables and enjoy an array of bites at one of OpenTable’s Top 100 Most Romantic Restaurants in America (2018).
Be sure to pair your meal with a drink from the bar. Not sure what will go best with your dinner? Feel free to ask the wait staff; part of Collage’s mission is the continued education of their waiters, bringing them to seminars on wine pairings, cocktails and food to better support your dining experience.
Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar
95 Cordova St.
St. Augustine, FL
Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar’s Reservations
St. Augustine’s beloved historic Grand Bohemian Casa Monica is more than just a relaxing resort; their sprawling campus is home to the impressive fine-dining restaurant, Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar. The dining experience boasts a “Coastal flavors, global influence” mission that combines Spanish and Moroccan cuisine with St. Augustine’s seaside location.
The moody dining space leans into the Spanish architecture of the building and Moroccan aesthetics with its decor and balances this with an attention to trendy touches that bring the space into the 21st century. This mosaic of designs is echoed in their menu, which features traditional Spanish and Moroccan dishes alongside modern plates, like truffle fries and black garlic Cesaer salad.
As you dine, enjoy the live music of local performers, from singers to guitarists and more. Top off the night with your pick from their handcrafted cocktails, like their house special, the Cordova Sour, made with Buffalo Trace, maple, egg whites, Angostura bitters and a touch of lemon.
Saint
44 Avenida Menendez
St. Augustine, FL
Saint’s Reservations
For Italian dishes that add heart to every meal, Saint provides a traditional Italian menu with elevated touches, like their 100-layer lasagna or their braised veal with blood orange carrots. Saint is not only a delicious dining experience but also a stunning one. The indoor and outdoor spaces provide an elegant, sophisticated and airy feel to your meal.
If you can, eat outside. Saint’s courtyard dining is an especially charming experience, especially at night when their string lights give the space a warm, soft glow. Or opt for their rooftop dining space around sunset to catch incredible views of the color-changing sky over the water.
La Nouvelle Bistro
102 Bridge St.
St. Augustine, FL
La Nouvelle Bistro’s Reservation
La Nouvelle is a great place for fresh food and an elevated dining experience that will have you feeling like you’ve just stepped into the pages of a fairy tale. Its decadent French dishes, beautiful kitchenware and option for garden seating feel more like an enchanted experience, with both brunch and dinner options.
The menu of French cuisine is made with St. Augustine ingredients thanks to the culinary team’s value in locally sourced produce, seafood and meats. For breakfast, try quiche, omelet, or bread pudding; then for dinner, dine on branzino or duck.
Let the minds behind the menu choose your meal for you by ordering the Chef’s Dinner Menu. For $85, you’ll experience a curated three-course meal with an appetizer, entree and dessert handpicked by La Nouvelle’s chefs. Add on a specialized wine pairing for an additional $35.
Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen
6 W. Castillo Dr.
St. Augustine, FL
Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen’s Reservation
Inside the Renaissance St. Augustine Historic Downtown Hotel is a hub for culinary passion and a love for handcrafted cocktails. Like the hotel, Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen’s dining space works with the existing historic bones of the region, featuring original brick and lofted ceilings with exposed beams as a way to showcase the old roots of their restaurant’s building. Much like their decor, their menu follows a similar path by chasing the passion that St. Augustine’s culinary scene has long established in the region.
Its menu dances between hearty tradition and one-of-a-kind plates, so whether you love a classic short rib or are daring to try the Portobello Stack, you’ll find your perfect dish in the folds of their menu. And with their use of local, fresh ingredients, you’ll get a bit of St. Augustine in every bite.
As you wind down the night, stop by their craft bar, where Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen adds their own twist to your favorites, like their Castillo Espresso Martini or their Blood Moon Fizz. Don’t drink? Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen has a mocktail menu that features the same artistic flair that they dedicate to their alcoholic drinks.
Vilano Beach
Michael’s St. Augustine
117 Vilano Rd.
St. Augustine, FL
Michael’s St. Augustine’s Reservations
Michael’s St. Augustine is a fine dining experience tucked inside the Hyatt Place St. Augustine/Vilano Beach, right by the water of Vilano Beach. Its menu ropes some of the seaside flavors in, with seafood taking a prominent spot on the menu alongside steak and other hearty comfort foods. The award-winning and storied chefs behind the menu, some of whom have even appeared on Food Network, pride themselves on curating dishes that highlight seasonal ingredients to ensure the freshest and most delicious components.
As you enjoy a bite inside the vine-covered, library-inspired restaurant, catch a live performance from a local pianist playing on Michael’s St. Augustine baby grand. Don’t forget to pair your meal with a glass from one of their many bottles available from their impressive wine library.
The culinary scene in St. Augustine navigates you through international cuisine with curated and storied chefs behind the plates, seats you at local hot spots with tasty favorites and sandwiches you between casual dining and elevated experiences. Discover more by visiting the Food & Drink page for all local eateries that are waiting to serve you.
Explore More
Related Content:
Lotus Noodle Bar56 Grove Avenue
St. Augustine, Florida 32084
Llama Restaurant415 Anastasia Blvd
St. Augustine, Florida 32080
Asado Life173 Shipyard Way
St. Augustine, Florida 32084
Ruth's Chris Steak House814 A1A N., Ste. 103
Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida 32082
Cordova Coastal Chophouse & Bar95 Cordova St.
St. Augustine, Florida 32084
La Nouvelle Bistro102 Bridge Street
St. Augustine, Florida 32084
Castillo Craft Bar + Kitchen6 W. Castillo Dr.
St. Augustine, Florida 32084
Michael's St. Augustine117 Vilano Road
St. Augustine, Florida 32084