Where to Find Pizza in St. Augustine and Ponte Vedra

Find pizza on Florida’s Historic Coast to match the day’s adventures. Pizza Time and Pizzalley’s serve slices on St. George Street in historic downtown St. Augustine, and Alfred’s pairs sourdough pizza with arcade games and live music in the West King District. Antonio’s and Bronx House Pizza offer New York-style pizza in St. Augustine Beach, Surfside Kitchen bakes brick-oven pies near Vilano Beach, and V Pizza specializes in wood-fired Neapolitan pies in St. Augustine and Palm Valley. In Ponte Vedra Beach, explore Al’s Pizza and Vincenzo’s Cucina, or head inland to Main St Pizza & Ice Cream in Hastings. For a Saturday farm outing, visit The Feed Mill for wood-fired pizza at Molasses Junction.

Whether the plan calls for a quick lunch between attractions, a relaxed Italian dinner or takeout after the beach, these pizza places offer plenty of ways to enjoy a slice of the destination.

Pizza Time

Stop at Pizza Time for Brooklyn-style pizza by the slice or a whole made-to-order pie. Located in the middle of St. George Street’s shopping district, this casual pizzeria makes a convenient lunch stop while exploring downtown. Choose from a rotating selection of slices, with options such as pepperoni, white pizza and margherita. Calzones and cannoli round out the menu. Bring cash; Pizza Time is cash only.

• Address: 124 St. George St., St. Augustine

Pizzalley’s and the Chianti Room

Choose a quick slice at Pizzalley’s or settle in for a longer meal at its connected full-service restaurant, Pizzalley’s Chianti Room. The St. George Street storefront serves pizza by the slice, while a passage leads toward the Chianti Room and its Italian menu. It’s a useful option when one outing calls for a quick bite and another calls for a leisurely dinner.

• Addresses: Pizzalley’s, 117 St. George St.; Chianti Room, 60 Charlotte St., St. Augustine
• [Learn More]

Carmelo’s Pizzeria

Discover New York-style pizza at Carmelo’s, attached to Carmelo’s Marketplace on King Street. The pizzeria makes its dough and sauce from scratch and bakes its pies in a brick oven. The menu also includes subs, calzones, stromboli and pasta, giving groups options beyond pizza. Its location near San Sebastian Winery makes it an option to consider when exploring the King Street area.

• Address: 146 King St., St. Augustine
• [Learn More]

Alfred’s

Spend an evening at Alfred’s, a quirky West King Street gathering spot that mixes food, music, art and games. The kitchen turns out fermented sourdough pizzas such as New York cheese, nduja, fungi, margherita and the Bee Sting, topped with pepperoni and local honey infused with Calabrian chili. Pastas, salads, beer and wine round out the menu. After dinner, play the arcade games on both floors, browse local art or catch the weekly live entertainment. Alfred’s opens at 4 p.m. daily and stays open late, making it a fit for a casual dinner or a night out; guests must be 21 or older after 9 p.m.

• Address: 222 W. King St., St. Augustine
• [Learn More]

Antonio’s Pizza

Make Antonio’s a stop after a day in St. Augustine Beach. Located on A1A Beach Boulevard near St. Johns County Ocean Pier, this New York-style pizzeria serves brick-oven pizza along with calzones, stromboli, subs and pasta. Order a pie to share or explore the Italian favorites for a meal that suits different appetites. Check the restaurant’s current hours before heading over, particularly on Friday afternoons.

• Address: 378 A1A Beach Blvd., St. Augustine Beach
• [Learn More]

Bronx House Pizza

Order a New York-style pie at Bronx House Pizza on A1A Beach Boulevard. The dough goes through a multi-step fermentation process, and signature pizzas include the Butcher Shop, the Chicken Parm Pie and the Hot 97, or build a pie with favorite toppings. Garlic knots, fried ravioli, subs, calzones, strombolis and pasta give the group plenty to share. Dine in at this family-friendly spot or order takeout or delivery after a day on the beach. Bronx House also has locations in Nocatee, St. Johns, Ponce and the Hammock area.

• Address: 1057 A1A Beach Blvd., St. Augustine Beach
• [Learn More]

Surfside Kitchen

Cross the bridge to Vilano Beach and dine a block from the ocean at Surfside Kitchen. This casual, family-friendly spot serves brick-oven pizza, with build-your-own pies and specialties such as pesto chicken burrata, mushroom truffle, arugula and prosciutto, Caribbean pineapple and margherita. Wings, salads, tacos and seafood round out the menu, and weekend brunch adds options such as chicken and waffles. Visit on a Tuesday evening for trivia or on a weekend evening for live music, and bring the dog along to the pet-friendly patio. Check current hours before heading over; Surfside Kitchen is closed on Wednesdays.

• Address: 85 Ava Way, Suite 105, St. Augustine
• [Learn More]

V Pizza

Explore a different pizza tradition at V Pizza, which serves Neapolitan-style pies cooked in wood-fired brick ovens. The dough uses 00 flour, and the restaurant highlights ingredients such as San Marzano tomatoes and buffalo mozzarella. Its approximately 13-inch pizzas have a lightly charred crust and a soft center, offering a different experience from a foldable New York-style slice. Find locations north of downtown St. Augustine and in Palm Valley in the Ponte Vedra area.

• Addresses: 5700 U.S. 1 N., St. Augustine; 154 Canal Blvd., Ponte Vedra
• [Learn More]

Al’s Pizza

Build a pizza around favorite toppings or choose a specialty pie at Al’s Pizza on A1A North. The Ponte Vedra menu includes meat, vegetable and chicken combinations, along with a Vegan Deluxe made with vegan cheese, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage and vegetables. That variety makes Al’s worth considering when the group includes diners looking for both traditional and plant-based pizza options.

• Address: 635 A1A N., Ponte Vedra Beach
• [Learn More]

Vincenzo’s Cucina

Pair pizza with a broader Italian dining experience at Vincenzo’s Cucina on Palm Valley Road. The restaurant offers hand-stretched pizzas alongside dishes such as lasagna, baked ziti and chicken piccata. Start with garlic knots or a salad, then choose a pizza or pasta entrée. It’s an option for an evening when everyone wants Italian food but doesn’t necessarily want the same meal.

• Address: 3787 Palm Valley Road, Ponte Vedra Beach
• [Learn More]

The Feed Mill

Make Saturday a countryside outing with wood-fired pizza at The Feed Mill, a family farm and farm store at Molasses Junction west of downtown St. Augustine. Share a handcrafted pie in a relaxed farm setting, then browse local produce, meat, eggs and dairy in the store. The combination of pizza, farm animals and country surroundings makes this a memorable stop for families exploring the agricultural side of Florida’s Historic Coast. Check The Feed Mill’s latest updates for Saturday pizza service times and special happenings before visiting.

• Address: 6400 C.R. 214, St. Augustine
• [Learn More]

Main St Pizza & Ice Cream

Head to downtown Hastings for New York-style pizza with dessert close at hand. Main St Pizza & Ice Cream prepares vegetables daily and serves pizza alongside garlic knots, salads and Italian favorites. Finish with an ice cream scoop, sundae, milkshake or Italian ice. Outdoor seating and takeout offer ways to fit a meal into a visit to this agricultural community on Florida’s Historic Coast.

• Address: 125 N. Main St., Hastings
• [Learn More]

Where can visitors get pizza by the slice in downtown St. Augustine?

Pizza Time at 124 St. George St. and Pizzalley’s at 117 St. George St. both serve pizza by the slice in historic downtown St. Augustine.

Where can visitors find wood-fired pizza in St. Augustine and Ponte Vedra?

V Pizza serves wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizza at 5700 U.S. 1 N. in St. Augustine and 154 Canal Blvd. in Palm Valley in the Ponte Vedra area.

Where can visitors enjoy Saturday pizza at a farm near St. Augustine?

The Feed Mill at 6400 C.R. 214 offers handcrafted wood-fired pizza on Saturdays in a family farm setting at Molasses Junction. Check its current updates for pizza service times.

Is there a vegan pizza option in Ponte Vedra Beach?

Al’s Pizza lists a Vegan Deluxe on its Ponte Vedra menu, with vegan cheese, vegan meats and vegetables. Confirm current ingredients and preparation details with the restaurant when ordering.

Where can visitors get pizza late in the evening in St. Augustine?

Alfred’s on West King Street serves sourdough pizza starting at 4 p.m. daily and stays open until 11 p.m. most nights and midnight on Fridays and Saturdays. Guests must be 21 or older after 9 p.m.

Where can visitors find pizza near Vilano Beach?

Surfside Kitchen at 85 Ava Way serves brick-oven pizza a block from the ocean near Vilano Beach, along with weekend brunch, trivia on Tuesdays and live music on weekends.

Where can families get pizza and ice cream in Hastings?

Main St Pizza & Ice Cream at 125 N. Main St. serves New York-style pizza and desserts including ice cream, sundaes, milkshakes and Italian ice.

Menus, hours and ordering options can change. Check with each restaurant for the latest details before visiting.